2013/08/05 | 5463 views | | Permalink
This drama starts out rather gloomily. Bullying, horrible injures, and death are a constant presence. The more significant factor, though, quickly turns out to be Shi-on (played by Joo Won). Even as a young child, Shi-on seems incredibly detached from the world around him. There's an emotional distance between him and all these trauamtic events that's puzzling, and to a certain extent inexplicable.
To other characters, anyway. It's obvious to us in the audience, who live in more enlightened times, that Si-on is on the autistic spectrum. I was impressed at how even-handed this drama was in demonstrating his unique abilities and social characteristics. Shi-on's autism is only really a negative in the sense that it changes how other people interact with him. In terms of general trauma, the detachment autism gives him actually makes it much easier for him to recover and move on.
It also endows him with exceptional skills in regards to medical diagnosis. As a child he easily grasps university-level textbooks and diagrams of the human form, and as an adult this skill has been transmutated into a genius-level understanding of the human body. We get to see this ability at work, and it seems clear that his mastery of medicine is unmatched.
The more significant problem this drama draws up is how Shi-on is going to interact with other people- something he clearly has trouble doing. He lacks the critical thinking power necessary to explain to people why they should listen to his opinion. The best he can do is act quickly and decisively and hope that he looks smart enough that no one will question him. Mind, Shi-on incapable of engaging in this kind of action deliberately- he lacks that kind of long-term thought process. So the minute he runs into someone situationally self-confident enough not to automatically believe the words of a complete stranger, there's trouble.
In my experience there's often a zoological approach whenever autistic spectrum individuals show up in fiction. The quirks will be overemphasized, even fetishized, and we're then left with a caricature as a result. Shi-on does not fit into these categories. From the very beginning we understand the world on his terms, and while it may not be an enviable life, as a way of coping it's about as good as any other. This conflict looks to be an appropriate fit with the world of medical dramas. Shi-on's difficulties are quite likely to have less to do with his quirks than they are with the unbending conservatism of the hospital hierarchical structure.
Review by William Schwartz
"[HanCinema's Drama Review] "Good Doctor" Episode 1"
by HanCinema is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
- Stay on topic and do not spam.
- Emoticons are fun, but actual thoughts are appreciated.
- Refrain from abusive language.
- Post only in English, as this is an English language community.
- Do not share pages or media unrelated to the topic you are commenting on.
- Do not request or mention illegal download/streaming services.
- No graphic content allowed.
- Respect the right of other users to share their opinion. Arguments are welcome, fights are not.
Comments which break the rules will be erased. Repeated rule breaking will result in blacklisting.
[HanCinema's Drama Review] "Who Are You - 2013" Episode 3
Si-On seems to have trouble making up her mind about the best way to get rid of the annoying ghost,...More
Good Doctor receives a high rating, enters in at number one
KBS2 drama "Good Doctor" sits at the top with a marginal difference of 0.9%. According to Nielsen,...More
Subscribe to HanCinema Pure to remove ads from the website (not for episode and movie videos) for US$2.99 per month (you can cancel anytime).
The first step is to be a member, please click here : Sign up, then a subscribe button will show up.