Director Jo Sung-hee's "Phantom Detective" is a play on the crime noir complete with anti-hero Hong Gil-dong (Lee Je-hoon), a decrepit town, deranged villains, and stylized filming that brings the world of the comic book to life. There are also two unlikely sidekicks, two little girls who rework Gil-dong's damaged psyche over the course of the film.
"Phantom Detective" was released in Korea May 4, 2016 and 508,000 filmgoers (19.9%) sat down to watch a modern take of the classic Korean tale of "Hong Gil Dong". Last weekend, May 13, 2016, the film premiered in Los Angeles and May 20 saw a wider North American release.
Jo Sung-hee made a big name for himself with his 2012 hit "A Werewolf Boy" starring Song Joong-ki and Park Bo-young. It, too, has a surreal ambience, set in the countryside with a touch of the fantastic. "Phantom Detective", although similar in whimsy, is distinctly set apart from it's predecessor by the cinematography, story, and quirky anti-hero.
Lee Je-hoon, in his first film role since military enlistment, plays the slightly deranged and very brilliant Hong Gil-dong, a man with a dark past like any self-respecting comic book hero. Lee is known for his spot-on portrayal of film characters, winning acclaim for films like "Bleak Night", "The Front Line", and "Architecture 101". "Phantom Detective" is another film in which he cleverly worked his character. Gil-dong is a man bent on revenge, but whose goals morph and change when he meets the grandchildren of the man who killed his mother, Dong-i (Roh Jeong-eui) and Mal-soon (Kim Ha-na). Both girls place an unfitting amount of good faith in the nearly immoral Gil-dong, but it is little sassy Mal-soon who challenges him to rethink his blind revenge and his dark lifestyle. (Kim Ha-na is quite the little actress as well!) The connection between Lee Je-hoon and the young actresses is real and present, which adds substance to the beautifully shot film.
We follow Gil-dong's search for the girls' beloved grandfather and Gil-dong's mother's murderer, Kim Byeong-deok (Park Geun-hyung) and discover clues with our detective as well as get sucked into the power plots of criminal organization Gwangeunhae. In many instances, we watch Gil-dong figure things out without being privy to his thoughts. Director Jo plays with the idea that Hong Gil-dong does right by people, but using less-than-moral means. Despite working with the girls who work change over the lifelong wounded Gil-dong, he still retains this aspect of his Robin Hood-like behavior.
What separates this film from being just-another-comic-book-film is the unique incorporation of cartoonish cityscape depictions into realistic portrayals of Gil-dong slinking about and performing his detective work, and the creative filters used to set scenes. I didn't much care for the overexposed desert scenes because the scenes were too washed out, but the result was intentional. Filming of Gil-dong's nemesis Kang Seong-il (played by the excellent chameleon actor Kim Sung-kyun) included purposefully reflecting light off of Kang's glasses so that only lenses can be seen to frame him as less human, a person we only see through a refracted surface. This is shown several other times through other reflective surfaces like windows and mirrors.
The musical score for this was magnificent and not intrusive. Many action-oriented films overdo the music to heighten feelings, but "Phantom Detective" did not. The same holds true for violent scenes. Although violence was presence, it was hinted at or show in limited exposure. In no way did this detract from the movie or from the impact of the violence on the characters involved. The balance by Director Jo between the different elements on screen is nicely done indeed. No sensationalism needed.
Humor also dotted the landscape of the drama, mostly between Gil-dong and the girls. His exasperation with the girls who constantly interrupt his mojo and their exasperation with his inability to tell a single truth are both endearing and humorous. This way of relating to each other spans the course of the film and their relationship. It grows deeper as the girls grow on him. Gil-dong self defines as a liar, but between him and the girls, he can only lie verbally. Small actions, like Mal-soon reaching for his hand and his surprised reaction hold the truth. His words belie his actions with them and it this fact that makes the relationship special. He always lies to them with words, but he is unable to lie in actions - such an interesting juxtaposition and one that Lee Je-hoon plays well. Other small bits of humor were found in his constant wheedling of money from President Hwang (Go Ara), his surrogate sister. Her role was minor and seemed more to include the talented and beautiful Go Ara, but the character does provide the backing he needs to do his work.
Smaller characters like the people in the village were also well-defined despite the fact that their roles were small. Personalities were immediately apparent, which is a sign of good writing. I detest when small characters are blips on the plot map. In "Phantom Detective" the villagers felt real.
For the most part, this film is worth the watch. I'll be watching it again. The neat resolution at the end is my biggest quibble. This doesn't mean it was a good or bad resolution. Please watch and see for yourselves!
Written by: Raine from 'Raine's Dichotomy'
For more information, please visit: www.cj-entertainment.com.
Los Angeles CGV Cinemas 5/13/2016621 S.Western Ave #304, Los Angeles CA 90010
Fullerton Regal La Habra 5/20/20161351 West Imperial Highway La Habra, CA 90631
DC Regal Fairfax Towne 5/20/2016Fairfax Towne Center, 4110 West Ox Rd Suite 12110, Fairfax, VA 22033
New Jersey NA Edgewater 5/20/2016339 River Road, Edgewater, NJ 07020
Dallas Cine Oasis 5/20/20161130 W. Trinity Mills Rd, Carrollton Tx 75006
Dallas AMC Grapevine Mills 5/20/20163150 Grapevine Mills Pkwy, Grapevine, TX 76051
San Francisco AMC Cupertino 5/20/201610123 N Wolfe Rd #3000, Cupertino, CA 95014
New York AMC Empire 5/20/2016234 W 42nd St, New York, NY 10036
Philadelphia AMC 309 5/20/20161210 Bethlehem Pike-suite B13, North Wales, PA 19454
Seattle AMC Alderwood 5/20/201618733-33rd Ave. West Lynnwood, WA 98037
Chicago AMC Showplace Niles 5/20/2016301 Golf Mill Center Niles, IL 60714
Atlanta AMC Sugarloaf Mills 5/20/20165900 Sugarloaf Pkwy, Lawrenceville, GA 30043
Honolulu Consolidated Pearlri 5/20/201698-1005 Moanalua Road, Aiea, HI 96701
Vancouver Cineplex S. C. Coqui 5/20/2016170 Schoolhouse Street, Coquitlam, BC V3K 4X9, Canada
Toronto Cineplex Odeon Yonge 5/20/201610 Dundas St E #402, Toronto, ON M5B 2G9, Canada
Managing editor, drama lover, and foodie, Lisa enjoys exploring Korea, speaking the language, and soaking in all that dramaland has to offer. Lisa Espinosa can be contacted via email@example.com.
"[HanCinema's Film Review] "Phantom Detective""
by HanCinema is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
Subscribe to HanCinema Pure to remove ads from the website (not for episode and movie videos) for US$0.99 monthly or US$7.99 yearly (you can cancel anytime). The first step is to be a member, please click here : Sign up, then a subscribe button will show up.